Compare Cable vs. DSL

Okay, so you are finally tired of those slow dial-up internet connections, and you want to go broadband. Good deal. But first, you may be wondering which type of broadband connection is best- DSL or Cable? Or, at least, which of the two gives you more speed for the price? Here we take a look at these two popular broadband connections and try to determine which one is better: DSL vs. Cable.

Cable Speed vs. DSL

The most common question that comes up is which type of connection is faster, DSL or Cable? To answer this, it is important to compare both upload and download speeds. Now, so you have something to compare these speeds to, your average dial-up connection is about 28 - 56 Kbps. Most often, however, you won't be able to get 56k through dial up, as most services can not handle this speed.

The average speed of a DSL download is 1.0 - 1.5Mbps. That's megabytes per second - about 20 times as fast as the fastest dial-up connection. This is fast, but consider Cable, which can give you up to 2 - 3Mbps. Thus, at least for downloading, cable can give you almost twice the speed of DSL - that's impressive. On the upload side, however, cable and DSL are pretty evenly matched. They both provide about 100Kbps - 400Kbps. It seems that cable has won this battle.

What about Price and Quality of Service?

There is more to discuss here besides the speed of the connections. Take price for one. Cable and DSL connections are both going to be more expensive than dial-up. But, DSL seems to be the cheaper of the two at the moment. You can get a good DSL internet connection for about $35 - $45 per month. Cable modem will cost you about $45 or $50 (this price may be included in a cable TV package). These prices, however, are really close and they change almost from month to month.

DSL is nice because you can talk on the phone and be online at the same time. In addition, business-level DSL service provides guaranteed data rates, so your connection speed is never a surprise. On the other hand, DSL speed tends to decrease the further you are away from the data center, and it is typically not as widely available as Cable. Cable speeds are not dependent on distance from the data center, and is occasionally cheaper than DSL when included in a cable TV rate. A cable modem, however, may require costly professional installation, and there may exists some limitations on downloads and uploads. All of these factors should be taken into consideration when choosing either broadband service.

Bradley James is a senior editor at SciNet.cc, a website containing many helpful consumer electronics review articles. For more information on DSL and Cable technology, please visit our DSL vs Cable webpage.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button


In The News:


CNET (blog)

STEVE FORBES: To Boost the Economy, Obama Should Keep His Hands Off the Web
FOXNews
... of a pro-growth regulatory regime won't find any comfort in the president's apparent fondness for net neutrality regulation of the broadband Internet. ...
The Struggle for What We Already HaveNew York Times
FCC launches further inquiry on net neutralityLexology (registration)
FCC seeks comment on two key elements of Google-Verizon net neutrality proposalZDNet (blog)
The Atlantic (blog) -The Hill (blog) -Pittsburgh Post Gazette
all 486 news articles »

CBC.ca

CRTC takes firm stand against big telcos
Globe and Mail
For Mirko Bibic, Bell's senior vice-president of government and regulatory affairs, the fact the regulator is telling Bell to roll out broadband Internet ...
Canada telcos told to extend broadband servicesReuters
Bell to appeal CRTC Internet rulingOttawa Citizen
Telus, Bell must repay customers, CRTC rulesVancouver Sun
National Post (registration) (blog) -Wall Street Journal
all 495 news articles »

Google Goes To $717 On Surging Net Traffic
Forbes (blog)
Broadband internet access is becoming widely available as well and greater price competition by broadband providers will help spur even further internet ...

and more »

Reuters UK

Time Warner Cable/Disney reach agreement, ESPN3.com and ESPN 3D included
Dallas Morning News (blog)
Time Warner Cable has about two million subscribers in Texas (including both TV and broadband Internet service subscribers) and about 14 million nationwide. ...
Disney, Time Warner OK cable dealFayObserver.com
Time Warner Cable Deal Brings Disney Into `TV Everywhere' FoldAutomated Trader
Breaking: Disney, Time Warner Cable Cut Dealmediabistro.com (blog)
Hollywood Reporter -Wall Street Journal -MarketWatch (press release)
all 713 news articles »

PhoneDog (blog)

Clearwire Introduces Rover: Instant Gratification to the Internet Addicted
MarketWatch (press release)
Rover does not require a credit card to activate service and is designed to bring broadband internet to a new audience. The Rover brand is designed for a ...
Rover Pay-as-You-Go 4G Mobile Broadband by Day, Week, Month- 2 Days FreeWireless and Mobile News (blog)
Clearwire Launches 4G Prepaid Mobile Broadband ServiceEverything PR
Clearwire announces Rover Pay-As-You-Go 4G Mobile Broadband ServiceBest Syndication
Wall Street Journal -ConnectedPlanet (blog) -PC Magazine
all 248 news articles »

Columbia Business Times

BlueBird Media building “middle-mile” broadband network
Columbia Business Times
... received a $45 million federal grant last month to build a broadband Internet network spanning 59 northern Missouri counties. BlueBird has six months to ...


Coming Soon: High Speed Internet Connections For Skyline Members
Boone Mountain Times
Today, that same drive and determination for better ways of communicating has been carried into the modern information age by the way of broadband Internet ...


TechEye

Broadband advertising 'misleading consumers'
Telegraph.co.uk
Consumers are left baffled by internet service providers' use of "up to" speed claims when defining the kinds of broadband internet connection speeds people ...
Broadband ads confuse puntersInquirer
Broadband advertisers 'need to be upfront about speeds'Broadband Finder
Virgin Media Starts Campaign To Clarify Broadband SpeedsITProPortal
The Guardian -Cable.co.uk (blog) -Mirror.co.uk
all 68 news articles »

Mobile Broadband Now Distorts National Broadband Stats
TMCnet
... downstream definition of broadband. Among the 35 million mobile wireless subscribers whose subscriptions included a data plan for full Internet access, ...
We're trudging down the long road to universal 4Mbps broadbandArs Technica
Ripe FCC Data: Our Broadband Is Still Pretty SlowBroadbandReports.com
FCC: Consumers Continue to Receive Slow Internet ConnectionsBroadbandBreakfast.com
Datamation -Nextgov -ConnectedPlanet (blog)
all 14 news articles »

St. Paul gets top ranking for speedy Internet
Minneapolis Star Tribune
Ookla does its surveys of broadband speed in an unusual way. Rather than contact Internet users, it relies on the results from two free websites ...

and more »
Google News

__________

Games at Buy.com

Kingston, Sandisk, Viewsonic, Canon, Toshiba

Broadband - Will it Affect Your Online Marketing Future?

The coming age of general Broadband use bearing down upon us, minute by minute, is going to leave many changes in its wake. Some will be welcome;... Read More

A Cheap Alternative To Broadband?

Are you a dial-up user looking for a faster connection, but don't like Broadband prices? If so, you should take a look at a new service called... Read More

Ka Band -Affordable Satellite Internet On The Way!

Ka Band VSAT* satellite internet technology has enormous possibilities for telecommuters, rural locations and eventually for Motor Home users around the U.S. - if it works! Ka... Read More

DSL Internet is a Simple and Easy Way to Get Fast Internet Service

DSL ? which stands for Digital Subscriber Line ? is a great way to get high-speed internet service, without having to get a cable modem, or live... Read More

The Coming Television Revolution

The revolution is just getting started and will be begin to make its mark this year. By 2010, it will begin to take off. By 2025, it... Read More

Wi-Fi Hotspot Security

You've set up your Boingo account, you're hanging out at the Home Turf sports bar in LAX and you figure you'll do a little business or check... Read More

Broadband is State-of-the-Art Internet Access: How Can a Broadband Cable Benefit You?

We are now well ensconced in a time when the Web is riddled with graphics, animations, sounds, and videos, bringing about a necessity for superior internet access... Read More

Remotely Connecting by Satellite To the Hospital - 2005

Hospital's and the Medical Professionals associated with them across America have discovered during the last few years that a great deal of efficiency can be accomplished by... Read More

Time to Redefine Telecom

Telecommunication, according to Wikipedia, is the extension of communication over a distance. In practice, it also recognizes that something may be lost in the process; hence the... Read More

What are Your Internet Connection Solutions?

Of primary concern to all internet users is their actual connection to the internet.A user needs to look at all the factors and weigh the benefits and... Read More

3 Tips to Fix Unreliable Wireless Connections

Generally speaking, wireless computer connections are reliable. However, nothing is perfect, and sometimes you may lose your connection or experience a weak signal. There are many factors... Read More

Why You Should Switch To A Fast Internet Connection

With high-speed Internet access becoming available in more and more areas, perhaps it is now available in your neck of the woods. If it is, you might... Read More

Business Satellite Internet Products Compared - 2005

There are a number of options available for Business Class Satellite Internet connectivity in the U.S. today. New offerings seem to launch every week in 2005 and... Read More

Google Brings Millions of Hard-to-Find Library Books to Your Fingertips

Millions of hard-to-find books from five major libraries will soon be a lot easier to access: Google has made plans to scan and digitize them, making the... Read More

Wifi Hotspot Locations for Sale..is that a Good Thing?

Recent companies have been advertising wifi hotspot locations that are 'turnkey' (they can run themselves), and only cost between $13,000 and $20,000 to start. Is that good?First... Read More

Understanding Broadband - Are You Ready To Upgrade?

Are you ready to upgrade your residential service to DSL or business service to real broadband or T1? Well, the answer lies in what you need. Before... Read More

Long Arm of the Law Reaches New Internet (RIAA, Internet-2, i2hub Lawsuit)

Have you heard of the new Internet? It's called Internet 2 and this time they're not fooling around. The Abilene Network , begun in 1999 provides the... Read More

Wireless Technologies in Mass Transit for Convenience and Safety

Modern Mass Transit is making it easier for commuters, especially with the latest inter connecting wireless technologies. Many buses, commuter trains, shuttles and even trolley cars now... Read More

Dreams Come True With The Help Of Global Consciousness On The Internet

Dreams. There are two types of dreams: 1. When you are sleeping there are stories unfolding in your mind from a parallel dimension. 2. The aims one... Read More

Finger Protocol - TCP-IP Suite

The "finger" protocol is used to return information on users on a specific host. Information that can be gained by using the finger is to see if... Read More

Whois Protocol - TCP-IP Suite

The Whois protocol is an information service not unlike the finger service. The Whois protocol provides the client or user with information about the owner of a... Read More

ICMP Protocol - Internet Control Message Protocol

The Internet Control Message Protocol communicates errors messages between systems that require attention. This error is not usually at the user level, the error is handled by... Read More

Some DSL Broadband Definitions

Often too many people get confused with all the definitions, here we have explained in easy to understand terms.ADSL: Asymmetric Digital Subscriber Line - asymmetric meaning it's... Read More

Compare Cable vs. DSL

Okay, so you are finally tired of those slow dial-up internet connections, and you want to go broadband. Good deal. But first, you may be wondering which... Read More

Internet Service Providers

Internet Service Provider or ISP is a company that provides access to the Internet.Before choosing an ISP, it is important to assess your company's business and marketing... Read More