Hedging Foreign Exchange Risks

Home
>
Currency Trading
>
Hedging Foreign Exchange Risks

Hedging Foreign Exchange Risks

The exchange rate of the Macedonian Denar against the major hard currencies of the world has remained stable in the last few years. Because of the IMF restrictions, the local Narodna (Central) Bank does not print money and there are no physical Denars in the economy and in the local banks.

Thus, even if people want to buy Foreign Exchange in the black market, or directly from the banks - they do not have the Denars to do it with.

The total amount of Denars (M1, in professional financing lingo) in the economy is around 200,000,000 USD, according to official figures. This translates into 100 USD per capita. Thus, even if each and every citizen of Macedonia were to decide to convert ALL their Denars to Deutsch Marks - they would still be able to buy only 150 DM each, on average. These tiny amounts are not sufficient to raise the rate at which DMs are exchanged for Denars (=the price of DMs in Denars).

But will this situation last forever?

According to economic theory scarcity raises the price of the scarce commodity. If Denars are rare - their price will remain high in DM terms, i.e. they will not be devalued against the stronger currency. The longer the Central Bank does not print Denars - the longer the exchange rate will be preserved.

But a strong currency (the Denar, in this case) is not always a positive thing.

The Denar is not strong because Macedonia is rich. The country is in a problematic economic situation. The banking system is perilous and unstable. The reserves of foreign exchange are minimal - less than 30 million USD.

The currency is stable because of externally imposed constraints and an artificial manipulation of the money supply.

Moreover, a strong currency makes goods produced in Macedonia relatively expensive in outside, export markets. Thus, it is difficult for Macedonian growers and manufacturers to export. When they sell their goods in Germany, they get DM for them and when they convert these receipts into Denars - they get less then they should have if the Denar reflected the true relative strengths of the two economies: the German one and the Macedonian one.

They pay expenses (e.g.: salaries to their workers, rent, utilities) in Denars. These expenses grow all the time as true inflation grows (as opposed to the official rate of inflation which is suspiciously low) - but they keep getting the same amount of Denars for their produce and products when they convert the DMs which they got for them.

On the other hand, imports to Macedonia become relatively cheaper: it takes less Denars to buy goods in DM in Germany, for instance.

Thus, the end result is a growing preference for imports and a decline in exports. In the long term, this increases unemployment. Export is the biggest driving force in creating jobs in modern economies. In its absence, economies stagnate and dwindle and people lose their jobs.

But an unrealistic exchange rate has at least two additional adverse effects:

One - as a rule, various sectors of the economy borrow money to survive and to expand.

If they expect the local currency to be devalued - they will refrain from taking long term credits denominated in hard currencies. They will prefer credits in local currency or short term credits in hard currencies. They will be afraid of a sudden, massive devaluation (such as the one which happened in Mexico overnight).

Their lenders will also be afraid to lend them money, because these lenders cannot be sure that the borrowers will have the necessary additional Denars to pay back the credits in case of such a devaluation. Naturally, a devaluation increases the amounts of Denars needed to pay back a loan in foreign currency.

This is bad from both the macro-economic vantage point (that of the economy as a whole) - and from the micro-economic point of view (that of the single firm).

From the micro-economic point of view short term credits have to be returned long before the businesses which borrowed them have matured to the point of being able to pay them back. These short term obligations burden them, alter their financial statements for the worse and sometimes put their very viability at risk.

From the macro-economic point of view, it is always better to have longer debt maturities with less to pay every year. The longer the credits a country (single firms are part of a country) has to pay back - the better its credit standing with the financial community.

Another aspect: foreign credits are a competition to credits provided by the local banking system. If firms and individuals do not take credits from the outside because they fear a devaluation - they help to create a monopoly of the local banks. Monopolies have a way of fixing the highest possible prices (=interest rates) for their merchandise (=the money they lend).

Access to foreign credits reduces domestic interest rates through competition with the local credit providers (=banks).

It would be easy to conclude, therefore, that it is an important interest of a country to be open to foreign financial markets and to provide its firms and citizens with access to sources of foreign credits.

One important way of encouraging people (and firms are made of people) to do things - is to allay their fears. If people fear devaluation - a responsible government can never promise not to devalue its currency. Devaluation is a very important policy tool. But the government can INSURE against a devaluation.

In many countries of the West, one can buy and sell insurance contracts called forwards. They promise the buyer a given rate of exchange in a given date.

But many countries do not have access to these highly sophisticated markets.

Not all the currencies can be insured in these markets. The Macedonian Denar, for instance, is not freely convertible, because it is not liquid: there are not enough Denars to respond to the needs of a free marketplace. So, it cannot be insured using these contracts.

These less privileged countries establish special agencies which provide (mainly export) firms with insurance against changes in the exchange rates in a prescribed period of time.

Let us examine an example:

The firm MAK buys combines and tractors from Germany. It has to pay in DMs.

An international development bank offered to MAK a loan to be paid back in 7 years time in DM.

Today, MAK would be so afraid of devaluation, that it would rather pay the supplier of the equipment as soon as it has cash. This creates cash flow problems at MAK: salaries are not paid on time, raw materials cannot be bought, production stops, MAK loses its traditional markets - and all in order to avoid the risks of devaluation.

But - what if the right government agency existed?

If governmental insurance against devaluation existed - MAK would surely take the 7 year loan. It would take, let's say, 10 million DM.

MAK would apply to the governmental agency with its business.

It would pay the government agency a yearly insurance fee of 2.5% of the remaining balances of the loan (as it is amortized and reduced with each monthly payment). This would be considered a proper financing expenditure and the firm will be allowed to deduct it from its taxable income.

The government will provide MAK with an insurance policy. An exchange rate (let us say, 30 Denars to the DM) will be stated in the policy.

If - at the time that MAK had to make a payment - the rate has gone above 30 Denars to the DM - the government will pay the difference to MAK in DM. This will enable MAK to meet its obligations to its creditors.

MAK will be able to cancel this insurance at any time. If, for instance, it suddenly signs a major contract with a German buyer of its products - it will have income in DM which it will be able to use to pay the loan back. Then, the government insurance will no longer be needed.

This very simple government assistance will have the following effects:

It will encourage firms to obtain foreign credits.
It will create competition to the local banks, reduce interest rates and encourage a wider and better range of services offered to the public.
It will encourage foreign financial institutions to give loans to local firms once the risk of re-payment problems due to a devaluation is minimised.
It will place Macedonia in the ranks of the more developed and export oriented countries of the world.
It will facilitate activities with longer term credits (such as modernization of plants for which longer terms of payments are required).

As time goes by, the private sector may step in and supply its own insurance against devaluation .

Insurance firms the world over do it - why not in Macedonia which needs it more than many other countries?

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com

In The News:

Ruble Rises Against Currency Basket After Central Bank Steps In
Bloomberg - 9 hours ago
Total currency trading volumes reached a record $8.5 billion yesterday, compared with daily trading of about $3 billion to $4 billion, said Denis Uvchukhov, ...
Russian assets tumble amid worries about ruble MarketWatch
Russian Stocks, Bonds Tumble as Central Bank Props Up Ruble Bloomberg
Georgia Sold 13% of its Reserves in August to Prop Up Currency Bloomberg
Bloombergall 23 news articles

KBS
Gov't to Ease Foreign Currency Trading Rules
KBS, South Korea - 10 hours ago
Most forms of personal foreign currency trading under ten-thousand dollars will be permitted starting next year. The Ministry of Strategy and Finance said ...

Turkish Press
Dollar slips from highs as yen gets stronger
International Herald Tribune, France - 5 hours ago
"Market players are cautious about unrest in global financial markets, which is strengthening sentiment for the dollar," said Kim Sung Soon, a currency ...
Land Of The Rising Yen Forbes
Yen Rises Against Euro, Dollar on Deepening Recession Concerns Bloomberg
Euro Heads for Weekly Drop as Slowdown Spreads Across Europe Bloomberg
Bloomberg - Bloombergall 411 news articles

National Business Review
NZ dollar takes a bath in choppiest trading in years
New Zealand Herald, New Zealand - 2 hours ago
"It's pretty much consistent with what we're seeing across the rest of the forex market," said Royal Bank of Canada currency strategist Sue Trinh. ...
Yen Heads for Weekly Gains on US Job Losses, Global Outlook Bloomberg
NZ dollar hits 12-month lows on risk, bonds firm Forbes
FOREX-Yen jumps as investors dump carry trades, flee risk Hemscott
FXstreet.com The Foreign Exchange Market - Bloombergall 136 news articles

Hindu Business Line
NSE currency futures trade drifts to realistic levels
Hindu Business Line, India - 42 minutes ago
“At present, banks are using currency derivatives only for proprietary trading. One will see real liquidity once customers start accessing the markets. ...

Mexico's Peso Declines for Second Week on Oil, Global Slowdown
Bloomberg - 53 minutes ago
... for global growth,'' said Omer Esiner, a senior market foreign-exchange analyst at Ruesch International Inc., a currency trading company in Washington. ...

Sebi Mulls FII Role In Currency Futures
TopNews, India - Sep 3, 2008
The regulatory body is examining the various currency contracts such as rupee-euro and rupee-yen. The present rules in India allow currency trading in ...
'Foreign investors will soon start trading in currency futures' India PRwire (press release)
SC notice to Sebi over Saurashtra exchange plea Daily News & Analysis
all 5 news articles

StarPhoenix
Canadian Dollar Weakens Before Report as US Currency Rises
Bloomberg - 22 hours ago
``Today it's just the normal back-and-forth trading before tomorrow's very important data and after the central bank indicated it will not raise rates,'' ...
Canada Morning: C$ Up As USD Suffers From Poor Aug Job Data FXstreet.com The Foreign Exchange Market
Longest losing streak in a year sends loonie to US93 cents Financial Post
Canada Morning: C$ Little Changed, Cedes Earlier Gains FXstreet.com The Foreign Exchange Market
FXstreet.com The Foreign Exchange Market - Bloombergall 127 news articles

How to profit from the falling pound
Reuters UK, UK - 10 hours ago
FX trading allows investors to ‘short the market' and speculate that a currency will continue to fall versus another currency and therefore gain returns ...

Wall Street Journal Blogs
Currency Trading’s Growing Asian Hub
Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY - Aug 28, 2008
A decade ago, some government officials in Southeast Asia lambasted currency traders, blaming them for driving down the value of many Asian currencies. ...

currency trading - Google News

Your Ad Here

Hedging Foreign Exchange Risks

Currency Trading Currency Trading